Chaptzem Blog!      

Cell-Phone M'Ishar, Kosher cell phone in America - Review - Pros and Cons

The so-called Kosher cell phone, the Cell-Phone M'Ishar, has finally made it to America. The cell phone, which is available to the Heimishe Oilem in America now, bears the symbol of approval by the Vaad HaRabonim that are in charge of approving cell phones for use as Kosher. The phone is a Samsung SPH A660 color screen flip phone with a nice big M'Ishar logo on the front and another one set as the phone's wallpaper. The phone functions as any other Sprint phone, only it has the internet and text messaging features locked out. Also, in order to help identify the M'Ishar users, every subscriber will have a phone number with a specific designated prefix that will be unique to M'Ishar users. Also when calling another phone from a M'Ishar phone the owner's name will not come up on the caller ID, rather the word M'Ishar and the phone number will come up instead.
Now, here are some of the main drawbacks to the M'Ishar Cell Phone. There is only one phone and one carrier available as of now. While the Vaad promises to continue to add phones as time goes by, how efficient can they really be. Further, to most people their phone number is like their name, how many people will be willing to give that up and change their number. Also, the model that was chosen is a very low-end old model without any of the new features that people have gotten used to. For example, the A660 has no caller ID screen on the front of the phone, forcing the person to have to open the flip each time he receives a call to see who it is. Also the A660 has no Bluetooth for hands-free talking. If they were going to put so much time and effort into this idea, they should have rather put it into a better phone. Further, the supposed Vaad did not make the effort to have the Samsung company delete the internet and messaging capabilities from the phone's software, but rather had them just lock it. The codes to unlock these features are already available on the internet, easily enabling the phone to seem Kosher while it really is not. Also, I wonder how many people are interested in having their caller ID come up as M'Ishar when calling someone, like maybe a business contact or something like that. Another point is, that there are many people that depend on e-mailing and text-messaging from their phone for business or announcements and reminders, is it realistically possible for these people to give this up. And what exactly is the concern about text-messaging anyway. Aside from all these points, what kind of bullying tactics will this Vaad impose in order to assure that people actually buy this phone. Will they start threatening to throw kids out of Yeshivah if their parents don't buy this phone? Will they throw pashkevilin at stores that continue to sell other phones that are not deemed Kosher? These are all questions that need to be considered before we let some unnamed Vaad claim power over us. Now, while Kosher cell-phones are a great idea, they have to be done the right way by the right people and they have to be overseen by trusted, truly responsible and truly Ehrliche Rabbonim.