Wednesday, June 28, 2006
Lakewood Shomrim head, Chaim Rubin, charged with attempted bribery of Rabbi beating cop, Erik Menck, and another
The township man behind a new neighborhood watch program — one police officials have yet to endorse because of concerns over how well it would work with law enforcement — has been charged with two counts of attempting to bribe a police officer.
Chaim Rubin, 25, was charged with trying to bribe Officer Erik Menck to help resolve traffic summonses involving Rubin's wife.
The second-degree felony charges against Rubin — each carrying a potential jail term of five to 10 years if he's convicted — predate his forming of Shomrim, a neighborhood watch program.
Shomrim, which roughly translates from Hebrew as "watchers," was formed in the wake of a still-unsolved sexual assault involving a young Orthodox woman.
But Shomrim isn't why Rubin — who declined comment Tuesday — was charged with two counts of bribing Menck. According to both his arrest warrant and an affidavit filed in state Superior Court, Toms River, this week:
Rubin's wife, Raizel, was stopped last fall by Lakewood Officer Michael Ruiz for an undisclosed motor vehicle violation. On Sept. 28, Rubin showed up at Menck's father's house and asked to speak to Menck.
Rubin said that Ruiz stopped Mrs. Rubin and, although the officer didn't have a ticket book on him, said he would later issue summonses. Rubin quickly arrived and told Ruiz that Rubin and Menck were friends.
When Menck and Rubin were finished talking, Rubin handed him an envelope and stated "I appreciate you talking to the other officer."
Rubin left, and when Menck opened the envelope, he found four $100 bills.
Menck talked with Ruiz to confirm Rubin's account and then reported the incident to his superiors in the Police Department.
Public Safety Director Al Peters said Tuesday he would not comment on the case.
Menck also gave a taped statement to Ocean County Prosecutor's Office Senior Investigator Todd L. Friedman, who set up another meeting with Rubin. Menck wore a wire and the conversation was recorded.
"Mr. Rubin acknowledged the $400 bribe and asked if the amount . . . was enough," Friedman wrote in the affidavit. "Mr. Rubin stated that "one hand washes the other' and that he would rather give Erik the money than the government. Mr. Rubin also refers to not needing the summonses and continued to tell Erik to enjoy the money. Mr. Rubin then alluded to offering more money to Patrolman Ruiz if needed."
Rubin and Menck met again Sept. 30. Rubin handed Menck $200 and "discussed that the money would go to Patrolman Ruiz." Rubin said another $100 could be paid, if needed.
On Oct. 7, Menck called Rubin to meet again. When they did, Rubin gave him $100.
Rubin, who lives on Malka Way and moved to Lakewood about two-and-a-half years ago, said Tuesday he could not comment without talking to his lawyer, Abraham Penzer. Penzer's office did not return a call for comment.
Rubin would not say what effect his arrest would have on Shomrim, which operates its own Web site and telephone hotline.
Robert A. Gasser, executive assistant Ocean County prosecutor, said the charges against Rubin were filed Monday because investigators wanted to wait to see if any more incidents of bribery would occur.
http://www.app.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060628/NEWS02/606280410/1070
The township man behind a new neighborhood watch program — one police officials have yet to endorse because of concerns over how well it would work with law enforcement — has been charged with two counts of attempting to bribe a police officer.
Chaim Rubin, 25, was charged with trying to bribe Officer Erik Menck to help resolve traffic summonses involving Rubin's wife.
The second-degree felony charges against Rubin — each carrying a potential jail term of five to 10 years if he's convicted — predate his forming of Shomrim, a neighborhood watch program.
Shomrim, which roughly translates from Hebrew as "watchers," was formed in the wake of a still-unsolved sexual assault involving a young Orthodox woman.
But Shomrim isn't why Rubin — who declined comment Tuesday — was charged with two counts of bribing Menck. According to both his arrest warrant and an affidavit filed in state Superior Court, Toms River, this week:
Rubin's wife, Raizel, was stopped last fall by Lakewood Officer Michael Ruiz for an undisclosed motor vehicle violation. On Sept. 28, Rubin showed up at Menck's father's house and asked to speak to Menck.
Rubin said that Ruiz stopped Mrs. Rubin and, although the officer didn't have a ticket book on him, said he would later issue summonses. Rubin quickly arrived and told Ruiz that Rubin and Menck were friends.
When Menck and Rubin were finished talking, Rubin handed him an envelope and stated "I appreciate you talking to the other officer."
Rubin left, and when Menck opened the envelope, he found four $100 bills.
Menck talked with Ruiz to confirm Rubin's account and then reported the incident to his superiors in the Police Department.
Public Safety Director Al Peters said Tuesday he would not comment on the case.
Menck also gave a taped statement to Ocean County Prosecutor's Office Senior Investigator Todd L. Friedman, who set up another meeting with Rubin. Menck wore a wire and the conversation was recorded.
"Mr. Rubin acknowledged the $400 bribe and asked if the amount . . . was enough," Friedman wrote in the affidavit. "Mr. Rubin stated that "one hand washes the other' and that he would rather give Erik the money than the government. Mr. Rubin also refers to not needing the summonses and continued to tell Erik to enjoy the money. Mr. Rubin then alluded to offering more money to Patrolman Ruiz if needed."
Rubin and Menck met again Sept. 30. Rubin handed Menck $200 and "discussed that the money would go to Patrolman Ruiz." Rubin said another $100 could be paid, if needed.
On Oct. 7, Menck called Rubin to meet again. When they did, Rubin gave him $100.
Rubin, who lives on Malka Way and moved to Lakewood about two-and-a-half years ago, said Tuesday he could not comment without talking to his lawyer, Abraham Penzer. Penzer's office did not return a call for comment.
Rubin would not say what effect his arrest would have on Shomrim, which operates its own Web site and telephone hotline.
Robert A. Gasser, executive assistant Ocean County prosecutor, said the charges against Rubin were filed Monday because investigators wanted to wait to see if any more incidents of bribery would occur.
http://www.app.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060628/NEWS02/606280410/1070
Comments:
Some people are so stupid. If you get a summons, handle it legally. If you're worried about points, then show up in court and plead guilty, you probably won't get points, even if you have to pay a fine.It's better to pay a fine than to try to bribe an officer - as we see from this unfortunate occurance.
dont ask for trouble Dont be such an ignorant fool
there is obviosly more to this story then you know!!!!
pd is out to get him because he founded shomrim thats quite obvious!!
He was setup!!!
there is obviosly more to this story then you know!!!!
pd is out to get him because he founded shomrim thats quite obvious!!
He was setup!!!
remember officer menck his name was on this blog many times 1 beating lakewood rosh yeshiva 2 beating black lady and many more why are lakewood people so stupid get this menck off the force
Can you explain to us exactly how he wa set set up when he on his own admission bribed a cop .
Set up means he was coerced or forced . Please explain.
Set up means he was coerced or forced . Please explain.
"set up" also means being "set up" by the cop - when the cop tells you i will take care of your problems for a few $$$ and you deliver - that is a "set up"
by law you law enforcement can not "lead" someone to do a crime
by law you law enforcement can not "lead" someone to do a crime
The alleged incidents were prior to forming of the Shomrim, so to say that he was setup is ridicoulous. On a side note, how come until this incident there was no name behind the shomrim and after this story all of a sudden everyone knows who founded shomrim??
It's called entrapment. Cops do it all the time.
It means he was led or goaded into it. It's like handing someone a loaded gun but disclaiming any responsibility when they use it to kill someone. Not to say the person pulling the trigger, or in this case ofering the bribe, isn't at fault, but from a technical legal perspective, at least with regard to the bribe scenario, he isn't "guilty"
It means he was led or goaded into it. It's like handing someone a loaded gun but disclaiming any responsibility when they use it to kill someone. Not to say the person pulling the trigger, or in this case ofering the bribe, isn't at fault, but from a technical legal perspective, at least with regard to the bribe scenario, he isn't "guilty"
R' Chaim Baruch is a good man with a big heart. Whether true or not, a kapittel tehillim for him wouldn;t hurt.
al tadin...
al tadin...
did you actually hear the alleged wiretap where he allegedly admits to doing it
VAAD OF LAKEWOOD you seem so sure of yourself
right away convicting a fellow jew who never did you any wrong!!!
shame on you Shame on us !!!
VAAD OF LAKEWOOD you seem so sure of yourself
right away convicting a fellow jew who never did you any wrong!!!
shame on you Shame on us !!!
did you actually hear the alleged wiretap where he allegedly admits to doing it
VAAD OF LAKEWOOD you seem so sure of yourself
right away convicting a fellow jew who never did you any wrong!!!
shame on you Shame on us !!!
Comment Credit ---This article posted by Anonymous : June 29, 2006 7:38 PM
...............................
with your logic that girl in lakewood was never abducted or rapedbecause you were not there to see so the whole story was made up according to you.
VAAD OF LAKEWOOD you seem so sure of yourself
right away convicting a fellow jew who never did you any wrong!!!
shame on you Shame on us !!!
Comment Credit ---This article posted by Anonymous : June 29, 2006 7:38 PM
...............................
with your logic that girl in lakewood was never abducted or rapedbecause you were not there to see so the whole story was made up according to you.
Well to start Mr. Rubin is not a bad person..
I was friends with Mr. Rubin prior to this event. Throughout life, people make some bad decisions. That does not mean that Mr. Rubin is a bad person. I take my job seriously and I do my job to the best of my ability. I treat everyone equally.
For the people that think the police don't like them, there is nothing more far from the truth. The reason we do our job is to help people... Everyone! A professional doesn't discriminate; a professional treats everyone equally.
If you think you can do the job better, I welcome you to try. Come work me , next to me.... experience
what we go through, what we go through for everyone because we care..
As always I put my name on what I write,
Erik Menck
and if anyone wants to ask me anything feel free to contact me art work.
Post a Comment
I was friends with Mr. Rubin prior to this event. Throughout life, people make some bad decisions. That does not mean that Mr. Rubin is a bad person. I take my job seriously and I do my job to the best of my ability. I treat everyone equally.
For the people that think the police don't like them, there is nothing more far from the truth. The reason we do our job is to help people... Everyone! A professional doesn't discriminate; a professional treats everyone equally.
If you think you can do the job better, I welcome you to try. Come work me , next to me.... experience
what we go through, what we go through for everyone because we care..
As always I put my name on what I write,
Erik Menck
and if anyone wants to ask me anything feel free to contact me art work.